Themes of The Shining City
When people are intractable in opposite positions, and too angry at each other to work out a compromise, there are no winners and losers — only losers on both sides.
Why This Series
The thesis
When people are intractable in opposite positions, and too angry at each other to work out a compromise, there are no winners and losers. There are only losers on both sides. As a society, we are at our best, in all ways, when we work together to find common ground and compromise. That is the thesis of this trilogy. The three books are one argument, told from three directions.
Book 1, Fall from the Left, is the book I have finished. I have tried to show how extremism on the Left, taken all the way through the institutions of a free country, can end in wreckage. The people who win that fight do not get to keep the country they thought they had saved. Nobody does. Book 2, Fall from the Right, turns the same lens on the other extreme. It considers what the United States would look like if extremists on the Right took full control of every lever of federal power. I suspect the country would still arrive at civil war, though the war would take a very different form. I will leave those particulars to that book. The ending I fear in both stories is the same: if we become intractable, both sides lose.
I do not believe, and I do not want the reader to believe, that the danger lives on only one side of the aisle.
Book 3, Thriving in the Center, is about the other half of the thesis. The best outcomes are not in one side's final victory. They are in holding moderate views, negotiating with those one does not agree with, and compromising for the good of all of society. Diversity of opinion, and the hard work of argument, negotiation, and compromise among people of all beliefs, is how we look out for each other as fellow citizens.
This is fiction, not a verdict on any party. I wrote these books because I love the United States, and because I do not want us to lose it. The themes that follow are the ground that argument stands on.
The thesis of the series is above. What follows is the ground it stands on: the walls, doors, and watchmen that hold a city together; the habits that undo them; and, in Book 1, the particular questions Fall from the Left takes up.
The Argument of the Trilogy
Walls, doors, and watchmen
A city, Nate's father told his sophomores, needs three things. Walls, to protect the people inside. Doors, so that the walls are not a prison and so that anyone with the will and the heart can come in. And watchmen, to keep the people safe: sheriffs and soldiers and courts, but also sound money, heat in the winter, and a fair start for every child. Take away any one of the three and you do not have a city. A door is only possible because there is a wall to hang it in. Take the wall away and you do not have an open door. You have an open field, and an open field belongs to whoever is strongest on it.
That lesson is the spine of the series. Book 1 follows a movement that decided it could do without all three, and sold the result with a slogan I still wince at: "a city without walls, open to all." Book 2 will keep the same picture and ask what happens when the other extreme takes its turn with the same institutions. Book 3 is about putting the walls, the doors, and the watchmen back in proportion, and keeping them there.
Books: 1, and the series as a whole.
Extremism, taken all the way
The series thesis is above: if we become intractable, both sides lose. What I have tried to do in the first two books is follow that claim into the institutions themselves. In Book 1, I follow a set of ideas on the Left not as a slogan and not as a talking point, but all the way through a free country, to see what is left when they have finished. Book 2 will do the same from the Right. I will not repeat those particulars here.
The point of telling both stories is not to split the difference. It is to be honest about the temptation that both sides share: the wish to win so completely that the other side no longer has to be lived with.
Books: 1 and 2; see also "Why this series."
Sincere people, and the slide from reform to coercion
I did not write a story about villains. The young man at the center of Book 1 loves his country and wants it to be kinder. So do most of the people who work beside him. They are not lying about the emergency they think they see. The danger is what happens when sincere people, sure they are going to do it right this time, stop talking with the people who do not want what they are building, and start building it so that refusal is no longer allowed.
Book 1 is the story of that slide, from reform into coercion, one law, one ruling, one quiet compromise at a time. The series will keep asking the same question of whoever holds the power: what do you do with the people who don't want it?
Books: 1 especially; the question runs through the series.
Making the next election powerless
A free country can survive a bad law. It is harder to survive a law designed so that the next election cannot undo it. In Book 1, that is not a suspicion the characters invent after the fact. It is a strategy written down early, and then carried out: through ordinary legislation, and through changes to the size and shape of the government itself.
I am not interested in scoring a single policy. I am interested in the habit of treating a temporary majority as a permanent one. That habit is not unique to one side, and it is one of the things the series is for: to show what a country becomes when winning once is meant to be enough.
Books: 1 in detail; the series explores the same temptation wherever it appears.
A country that stops talking
The line I keep coming back to is not a speech in Washington. It is a question asked at a kitchen table in Lima, Ohio, on an election night, by a father to a son: "What happens to the people who don't want it?" The son laughs, and says they will come around.
Book 1 is, among other things, a family story: people who love each other and do not vote the same way, and who have to go on living in the same house, and then in the same country, while the space between them widens. I think loving your country means being able to talk with the people you disagree with. When that talking stops, the line that follows is not only political. It runs through households, and then, in this story, across a map.
Books: 1 especially; the series as a whole.
History, read too late
Nate's father puts a book in his hands at twenty-three and asks him to read the history first, then decide. The son does not. He is sure that the warnings belong to someone else's country, written in another language, about people who had simply done it wrong. His generation, he later says, was going to do it right. That is what every generation that has tried it has believed.
I am not writing these books to mock the young. I am writing them so that someone sitting where that young man sat might spend the evening he did not. Book 1 is about a generation that learned the cost too late, and in person. The series is for the ones who still have time.
Books: 1 especially; the series as a whole.
The center: argument, negotiation, and compromise
The second half of the thesis is that we are at our best when we work together to find common ground. Book 3, Thriving in the Center, is where that work is done. I will not pretend I have already written that book, and I will not repeat the case I made above.
What I will add is how I think the center actually holds. It is not the absence of disagreement. It is the hard work of the adversarial process — argument, negotiation, and compromise among people of all beliefs. Everything in Book 1, and everything I intend for Book 2, is pointed toward that work.
Books: 3 primarily; see also "Why this series."
Not a verdict on a party
I have already said that this is not a verdict on any one party, or on the ordinary men and women who belong to one. The characters in Book 1 include people who believe in the movement and people who resist it, and I have tried to be fair to the sincerity of both.
If you come to these books looking for a team to cheer, you will be disappointed. If you come looking for a country worth keeping, I wrote them for you.
Books: the series as a whole.
Freedom is never more than one generation away
I have written these books because I love the United States and do not want us to lose the greatest nation, economy, and society in world history. Ronald Reagan said that freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. I think he was absolutely correct, and I think we are losing sight of that as we divide into two extremes that cannot coexist.
For the sake of our children and grandchildren, we have to do the work I set out in the thesis: find common ground, and keep the country they will inherit. That is not a plot point. It is why the trilogy exists.
Books: the series as a whole.
What Book 1 Looks At in Particular
Book 1 does not argue these questions in the abstract. It follows them into ordinary lives: a swim lane, a job site, a sheriff's office, a kitchen table, a winter without heat. What follows is the ground of Fall from the Left. Book 2 will not simply repeat this list from the other direction; I will leave those particulars to that book. Book 3 is about how we might avoid needing any of this wreckage at all.
Protected spaces
A wall is not only a border. It is also a category that exists for a reason: a lane, a team, a space in which the people it was built for can compete and be safe. Book 1 begins that argument with a high-school hill and a college race, and it tries to be fair to everyone in the water. The young woman who wins did not write the rule that let her swim there. The young woman who loses, and the coach who says girls deserve their own lane, are not villains either.
The question the book asks is the same one the rest of the trilogy asks about walls: what is lost when a protected space is treated as if it were an injustice in itself.
Books: 1.
Family, and what we tell the young
A city, in the lesson Nate's father taught, includes a fair start for every child. Book 1 also asks what happens to a country when fewer children arrive, and when the culture stops telling the young that the family a man and a woman make, and the children they raise, are worth it. I have tried to be honest about the economic pressures that are already on the record — housing, debt, the cost of starting a life — and not to pretend that one cause explains everything.
This is a question the novel explores through its characters, not a lecture I am trying to win in advance. I will leave readers to judge it for themselves.
Books: 1.
Who is left to stand the watch
Watchmen are not only sheriffs. They are also the people who are willing to serve. Book 1 follows what happens when the communities that have long sent their sons and daughters into uniform stop sending them, and when a force that was already under strain is asked to do more with less. By the time the country reaches its confrontation, the question is no longer only what the government believes. It is who is still there to carry it out, or to refuse it.
Books: 1.
An open door with no wall around it
I believe in doors. A country without them is a prison. Book 1 also takes seriously what happens when the door is taken off the wall and the people who live next to the opening — the contractor whose day rate is cut, the mother in an emergency room, the town paying the bill — feel the cost first. A door with no wall around it is not an open door. It is just an open field.
The book is not an argument against arrival. It is an argument against pretending that arrival has no conditions and no cost, and that the cost is not borne by someone.
Books: 1.
Repair, and the bill that follows
Book 1 takes a proposed national repair, one already argued in public in our own time, and asks a novelist's question: what if it were carried out in full, largely at once, and paid for in cash and in new debt? The story that follows is not a budget table. It is what ordinary people feel when the bill comes due — in prices, in the bond market, and in the stability of everything that depends on both.
I will not tell you, here, that the impulse to repair is wicked. I will tell you that good impulses, funded without limit and without patience, have consequences, and that the people who feel them first are not always the people who voted for them.
Books: 1.
When vetting fails
Doors require watchmen. Book 1 follows what happens when the screening at the entrance fails, or cannot keep up, and when violence that should have been rare starts to feel ordinary. It also follows the other half of that failure: the backlash that lands on innocent people, and the new machinery of surveillance that ordinary citizens come to feel is aimed at them.
The book is not a claim that every stranger is a danger. It is a claim that a country which will not distinguish has to live with both the danger and the suspicion that follow.
Books: 1.
Taxes at every level
None of a movement's program is free. Book 1 imagines a government that tries to enact a great deal of it at once, on top of a country that already spends more than it collects, and then follows the bill into household life: what is owed, at every level, and what is left after it is paid. I am less interested in a rate than in a habit — the habit of treating the public's wallet as bottomless, and of discovering, too late, that it is not.
Books: 1.
Debt, and the day the credit runs out
Sound money is one of the watchmen in the old lesson on the board. Book 1 takes the country's real indebtedness as its starting point and asks what follows if borrowing is pushed far enough, and fast enough, that the people who lend the government money stop believing they will be paid in something worth having. In the story, that day has a name, Black Thursday, and it arrives before the split. The point is not the name. It is the ordinary damage: mortgages, pensions, jobs, the quiet systems people only notice when they break.
Books: 1.
Heat in the winter
Watchmen, in that same lesson, include heat in the winter. Book 1 asks what everyday life looks like when an ambitious energy program is written into binding law and placed on a grid that is already short of reliable power. The winters in the story fail for more than one reason: too little dispatchable power, extreme weather, and deliberate attacks. I am not telling a fable in which one kind of fuel is the villain. I am asking what happens to families, and to a country, when the lights go out and stay out.
Books: 1.
Sending the watchmen home
A city that sends its watchmen home will find out, soon enough, who arrives in their place. Book 1 follows a movement that treats police and prisons as problems to be reduced toward zero, and then lives with the result: calls that go unanswered, men released with nowhere to go and no one to meet them, and sheriffs left as the last law in places that still have to be lived in. A mother in a bathrobe, late at night, asks a sheriff the question the book cannot shake: "Who do you work for? Them? Or us?"
I have tried not to forget the reasons people wanted a gentler system. I have also tried not to look away from who pays when the system is no longer there.
Books: 1.
Ideas taken to their end
Movements get captured. In Book 1, the faction that captures this one is not a cartoon and is not a stand-in for ordinary voters. It is a group of people who mean to carry a set of old teachings through to their logical end, and who find, in a moment of political victory, the power to try. The irony, in the story, is as old as the teachings themselves: the people who talk most about liberation become, in office, the people who most want everyone else's hands emptied.
The book is a novel about that capture, not a pamphlet about a philosopher. I will leave the documents, and the arguments, to the pages where they belong.
Books: 1.
Registration, confiscation, and closed doors
Book 1 follows a long ratchet: from measures many sincere people can support, through registration and buyback, and finally to a national law that makes a private firearm a felony. It asks what happens when a government orders that last step in a country where tens of millions of people already own guns, and where a great many of them, and a great many of the sheriffs and legislatures who live among them, will not comply. The answer, in the story, is convoys, closed doors, and a morning no one is able to take back.
I have tried to be fair to the sincerity of the people who wanted the guns gathered up, including people who had lost someone to gunfire. I have also tried to be honest about what a state becomes when it decides that the last closed door in a free country is the one it is entitled to kick in. I will not tell you, here, how that morning ends. The book will.
Books: 1.
See how these fictional turning points compare with real present-day trends—and why both sides have a stake in stepping back.